Affordable Housing Finance in Pakistan–Opportunities and Challenges

Introduction

Pakistan faces a severe housing shortage, with estimates suggesting a deficit of over 10 million units, disproportionately affecting low- and middle-income families. The demand grows by approximately 700,000 units annually, yet supply remains critically low due to financial, regulatory, and infrastructural constraints. Affordable housing finance presents a significant opportunity to bridge this gap, but systemic challenges hinder progress.

This report explores the current state of housing finance in Pakistan, identifies key opportunities for growth, and examines the barriers that must be addressed to unlock the sector’s potential.

The Housing Crisis in Pakistan

1. Magnitude of the Problem

Pakistan’s urban population is expanding rapidly, with nearly 40% of people now living in cities. However, formal housing supply has not kept pace, leading to:

• Informal settlements (katchi abadis): Over 50% of urban dwellers live in unplanned, often illegal, housing.

• Unaffordability: Even middle-income families struggle to secure mortgages due to high interest rates and stringent lending requirements.

• Rural-urban migration: Cities like Karachi, Lahore, and Islamabad face extreme pressure, with demand far outstripping supply.

2. Economic and Social Impact

The housing shortage exacerbates poverty, inequality, and social instability. Without secure housing:

• Families remain trapped in cycles of informal renting.

• Economic productivity suffers due to long commutes and poor living conditions.

• Government welfare programs struggle to address homelessness and slum proliferation.

Current State of Housing Finance in Pakistan

1. Limited Mortgage Penetration

Pakistan’s mortgage-to-GDP ratio is just 0.5%, among the lowest in South Asia (compared to India’s 11% and Bangladesh’s 3%). Key reasons include:

• High interest rates: Most banks offer mortgages at 15-20%, making loans unaffordable.

• Short tenures: Typical mortgage terms are 10-15 years (vs. 20-30 years in developed markets), increasing monthly payments.

• Strict eligibility: Banks require high collateral and steady formal income, excluding many informal workers.

2. Role of Banks and Non-Bank Financial Institutions (NBFIs)

• Commercial banks dominate housing finance but focus on high-income borrowers.

• Government-backed institutions (e.g., House Building Finance Corporation, HBFC) have limited reach and liquidity.

• Microfinance banks serve lower-income groups but offer smaller, short-term loans unsuitable for housing.

3. Islamic Housing Finance

Sharia-compliant financing (e.g., diminishing musharaka) is growing but remains a small segment due to complexity and lack of standardization.

Opportunities in Affordable Housing Finance

1. Government Initiatives

• Naya Pakistan Housing Program (NPHP): Aims to build 5 million affordable homes, with subsidies for low-income buyers.

• Tax incentives: Reduced withholding taxes and stamp duties for affordable housing projects.

• State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) policies: Mandates for banks to allocate 5% of lending to construction and housing.

2. Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs)

Collaborations between developers, banks, and the government could:

• Lower land costs through subsidized plots.

• Streamline approvals for affordable projects.

• Improve infrastructure (roads, utilities) in new housing schemes.

3. Technology and Innovation

• Digital mortgage platforms could simplify applications and reduce processing times.

• Alternative credit scoring (using utility bills, mobile payments) could help informal workers qualify for loans.

• Prefabricated construction may cut costs and speed up delivery.

4. Foreign Investment and Donor Support

• International organizations (World Bank, ADB) are funding affordable housing projects.

• Diaspora bonds could attract remittances into housing finance.

Challenges and Barriers

1. High Cost of Construction

• Land prices: Speculation and inefficient land use inflate costs.

• Building materials: Imported steel and cement keep prices high.

• Regulatory fees: Multiple approvals and taxes add 20-30% to project costs.

2. Weak Legal and Regulatory Framework

• Property title disputes: Poor land records lead to litigation, deterring lenders.

• Foreclosure delays: Courts take years to resolve defaults, increasing risk for banks.

• Zoning restrictions: Rigid master plans limit high-density affordable projects.

3. Lack of Long-Term Funding

• Banks rely on short-term deposits, making long-term mortgages risky.

• No robust secondary mortgage market to free up liquidity.

4. Cultural and Behavioral Factors

• Preference for self-build (gradual construction) over mortgages.

• Distrust of formal financial institutions.

Recommendations for Growth

1. Policy Reforms

• Land reforms: Digitize records, release government-owned land for housing.

• Foreclosure laws: Expedite legal processes to protect lenders.

• Interest rate subsidies: SBP could offer refinancing at lower rates for affordable housing loans.

2. Financial Sector Development

• Expand mortgage insurance to reduce lender risk.

• Develop REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) to attract institutional investors.

• Encourage Islamic housing finance with standardized products.

3. Strengthening Stakeholder Collaboration

• Developers, banks, and government must align on pricing, subsidies, and approvals.

• NGOs can assist with community-based housing solutions.

4. Awareness and Financial Literacy

• Educate consumers on mortgage benefits and responsibilities.

• Promote rental housing as an interim solution.

Conclusion

Affordable housing finance in Pakistan presents immense economic and social potential but requires coordinated efforts across policy, finance, and construction sectors. While challenges like high costs, weak regulations, and limited access to credit persist, opportunities in government programs, technology, and PPPs offer a path forward.

By addressing structural barriers and fostering innovation, Pakistan can unlock housing finance as a driver of inclusive growth, providing millions with secure, dignified living spaces while stimulating broader economic development.

Also Read: Housing in Hungary: Debt and Degrowth